In Marbury v. Madison in 1803, the US Supreme Court concluded that William Marbury had a right to his commission, but that the Court could not grant the order he requested in the way he had brought the case. The decision is a landmark in the Court's exercise of judicial review.
Follow the three questions
Marbury was appointed a justice of the peace near the end of John Adams's presidency. His commission was not delivered. He asked the Supreme Court to issue an order directing Secretary of State James Madison to deliver it.
Chief Justice John Marshall examined whether Marbury had a right to the commission, whether the law offered a remedy, and whether the Supreme Court had jurisdiction to issue that remedy as an original matter. The first two questions did not resolve the third. The Court read the relevant statute as enlarging its original jurisdiction beyond the Constitution's limits. When the statute and Constitution conflicted, the Court applied the Constitution.
Keep the holding separate from its significance
For an exam outline, write down both outcomes. Marbury did not obtain the order he wanted. The Court nevertheless established a lasting example of declining to enforce a federal statute it concluded was unconstitutional. That distinction explains why someone who lost his immediate case is associated with a decision about the Court's institutional power.
Use the National Archives document and its transcript to check the wording of the opinion.
Continue with Oakgen Agent
Open in Oakgen Agent
The prompt is filled in for you. Review it before sending.


