An editor can preserve the broad silhouette of a product and quietly fill in a narrow hole. This matters for handles, wall brackets, and tool photography. Compare how operations treat the small negative space after a color edit so an output does not misrepresent the object.
Build the test input
Make a simple product photograph of a handle with an oblong cutout and a squared upper corner. Save the background separately. Ask to change only the handle body from lilac to olive, with the opening left unchanged. Place the same reference image into every compatible variant.
Run the proposed comparison
Generate a matched set at the same available output size. Save an unchanged image with the original cutout highlighted to ease alignment later. Record whether each tool consumed an exact mask, an annotated image, or unassisted wording. Do not conflate input modes with model strength.
Decide what passes
Sample the narrowest part of the opening. If solid fill replaces background or the new contour can no longer be attached to the frame outline, reject it. Be alert to simple compression or edge halos, which can look like filled pixels on a poorly scaled preview.
Act on the outcome
When a variation makes a good approved color edit but loses the opening, reinsert the protected pixels using the original as a layer. If that repair leaves obvious color discontinuities at the joining edge, try a narrower masked edit or relight the original product before choosing the model.

