A video edit that switches a table lamp can also change the dress, paint, or face color. Build a simple intervention with named untouched areas. The point is to measure the concentration of the edit, rather than selecting the most dramatic new frame.
Build the test input
Shoot or assemble a short living-room plate with a lamp on the right, a neutral gray folder beside it, and a subject at the left edge. Ask for the lamp shade to turn from off to warm amber while the folder, framing, and left-side light stay the same.
Run the proposed comparison
Match exported duration and crop before comparing. If one operation accepts a mask, save the mask and trial a comparable unmasked version separately. Pick a small folder patch outside the illuminated region. Keep the original plate as an alignment reference through the whole edit.
Decide what passes
Expected change includes a bulb glow and plausible light immediately around the lamp. Treat an overall color wash, a repositioned folder, and a changed face as separate defects. A stronger glow is useful only if it preserves the boundaries outside the requested intervention.
Act on the outcome
When the edit bleeds beyond the lamp, a localized overlay in the finishing editor can be the more reliable solution. Reserve model edits for material or shape changes whose clean isolation you can verify after export. Do not infer broad editing accuracy from a single lighting pass.

