Two films named Jack Frost use a snowman for very different stories. The names that separate them fastest are Michael Keaton and Michael Cooney. Keaton appears in the 1998 comedy-drama directed by Troy Miller. Cooney directed the horror comedy starring Scott MacDonald.
Check the listing for the right film
The American Film Institute lists the 1998 Jack Frost as a PG comedy-drama with Michael Keaton and Kelly Preston. Its premise centers on a father who gets another chance to reconnect with his son through a snowman. Use Troy Miller’s directing credit or Keaton’s name if a rental page shows little else.
Vinegar Syndrome describes Cooney’s Jack Frost as a horror comedy about a killer who becomes a snow creature after a crash and terrorizes a town. It lists Scott MacDonald and Christopher Allport in the cast. The distributor lists 1996, while MVD’s collector’s edition lists 1997 as the production year. The director and cast are more reliable identifiers for this film than the year alone.
Save an unambiguous watchlist entry
Instead of saving just “Jack Frost,” use “Jack Frost — Troy Miller, Michael Keaton” or “Jack Frost — Michael Cooney, Scott MacDonald.” For a film club, add a line about tone and audience so anyone opening a listing can check their choice without reading a detailed plot summary. The same method works for remakes and other films with overlapping titles.
Continue with Oakgen Agent
Open in Oakgen Agent
Review the prefilled prompt before sending.


