Choose a traditional opener if you want the fastest, most familiar tool and can live with a sharp lid; choose a safety opener if smooth edges and a cleaner blade matter more than a learning curve. America's Test Kitchen, Consumer Reports and Serious Eats all tested both types and reached different conclusions, which is why this guide compares their reasoning instead of naming one universal winner.
How the two designs cut
America's Test Kitchen (ATK) explains that both styles use a driving handle you turn to propel a small circular blade around the lid. The difference is where the blade cuts:
- Traditional openers puncture the top and cut downward inside the rim. The severed lid is sharp and drops into the can, and the can wall can be jagged.
- Safety openers cut horizontally into the side, usually the rim itself. The lid has no sharp edge, can be lifted with the opener and can often be put back on the can.
ATK adds that traditional openers are somewhat faster because their larger cutting wheels and longer handles cover more ground and give more leverage, and that you get feedback: a hiss of air, and a visible lid sinking. Safety models give little of that feedback and take practice. After opening, you may see glue strings on the lid, which ATK calls harmless and unlikely to get into food.
What the three test programmes did
| Source | What they tested | Headline finding |
|---|---|---|
| America's Test Kitchen (Aug 2024) | Traditional and safety openers on 15-oz bean, 5-oz tuna, 6-oz tomato paste and 28-oz tomato cans; hand washing five times | No single right answer; named a favourite of each type |
| Consumer Reports (Sep 2026) | 10 openers: four traditional, three automatic, three safety, used by five older testers and three staff | Top pick was a traditional manual opener; safety openers generally disliked |
| Serious Eats (updated Jun 2026) | 11 openers on small, medium and large cans plus a cleaning test | Simple two-handled openers were easiest; safety models fiddly |
ATK notes that a decade ago it chose a safety model and a few years ago a traditional one. Consumer Reports says its testers scored efficacy, ease of use and the hand strength needed. Serious Eats says all but one of the openers it tested (a KitchenAid model that mostly latched, unlatched and spun without cutting) could open a can, and comfort separated the rest.
Features testers rewarded
- A long driving handle. ATK explains it acts as a lever, so a longer handle needs less force. As an illustration, ATK lists a 3 in driving handle for the OXO and 3.5 in for another recommended traditional model it describes as having one of the longest handles it tested. For the same turning effort (torque = force x length), the longer handle needs about 14% less force (3 divided by 3.5 is 0.857). Real openers also depend on gears and blade sharpness, so this is only the lever part.
- Grippy arms. ATK preferred textured metal or rubbery sheaths; Serious Eats likewise praised silicone-coated handles and big knobs.
- For safety openers, a shallow cut into the rim. ATK found openers that cut below the rim removed the whole top, which left walls sometimes sharp and cans more flexible and harder to pour from.
- Light weight, where it matters. ATK says safety openers usually weigh 4 to 6 ounces, about half of a traditional model.
Care and lifespan
ATK says can openers almost always fail eventually: metal rusts, blades dull and grips loosen. Dry the opener thoroughly after washing and put a drop of mineral oil on the gears now and then. It also notes that a safety opener's blade never touches the contents, so it stays cleaner.
You can use a traditional opener in safety style by placing it on top of the can with the cutting wheel outside and the gear on the inner rim, but ATK says the can top will then be sharp and the can loses structural integrity, so it recommends buying a proper safety model instead.
Whichever you buy
The USDA's Food Safety and Inspection Service advises discarding cans that are dented, leaking, bulging or rusted. No opener makes a damaged can safe.
A quick decision guide
- Hands that tire easily: consider a safety opener, since ATK says it locks on without squeezing, or an electric model.
- Occasional use, minimal fuss: a traditional opener with a long handle and grippy arms.
- Worried about sharp lids or hygiene: ATK says a safety opener leaves no sharp edges and its blade never touches the contents.
- Not sure: borrow both types and test on one 15-ounce can each.
Take this further with Oakgen Agent
Agent can ask clarifying questions, compare opener types from the sourced criteria, search the web for current reviews and write a printable checklist as a document.
Looking for a recap of one specific YouTube video? The YouTube Summarizer does that today.
Open this task in Oakgen Agent
The prompt is filled in for you. Nothing is sent until you press send.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a traditional and a safety can opener?
America's Test Kitchen explains that both use a driving handle that turns a small circular blade around the lid. A traditional opener punctures the top and cuts downward inside the rim, leaving a sharp lid that drops into the can. A safety opener cuts horizontally into the side, usually at the rim, leaving smooth edges, and often lifts the lid off with the opener.
Which can opener did America's Test Kitchen pick?
In its review published on 8 August 2024, America's Test Kitchen named the OXO Good Grips Soft Handled Can Opener its favourite traditional model, the EZ-DUZ-IT a close alternative, and the Kuhn Rikon Auto Safety Lid Lifter its favourite safety model. It also says its past winners have alternated between safety and traditional types, so there is no single right answer.
Do safety can openers have drawbacks?
Testers report a learning curve. America's Test Kitchen says they attach differently, give little feedback when latched, and take slightly more force to turn. Consumer Reports' September 2026 article says its testers generally found safety openers awful to use, while Serious Eats calls them fiddly but safer on edges.
When should I throw away a can instead of opening it?
The U.S. Department of Agriculture's Food Safety and Inspection Service advises discarding cans that are dented, leaking, bulging or rusted. The tool you use does not change that rule.
Sources
- America's Test Kitchen, The Best Can Openers of 2024, Miye Bromberg (published 8 Aug 2024; read 2026-11-19)
- Consumer Reports, We Opened 100 Cans to Find the 3 Best Can Openers, Ginger Cowles (14 Sep 2026; read 2026-11-19)
- Serious Eats, The 6 Best Can Openers of 2026, Tested and Reviewed, Grace Kelly (updated 24 Jun 2026; read 2026-11-19)
- USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service, Keep Food Safe! Food Safety Basics (last updated 5 Jan 2024; read 2026-11-19)


